44 Comments

It’s funny how Muslims cry out over Islamophobia in India, but are silent when it comes to confronting internal discrimination and extremism within Islam itself? Why does Islam pose issues with Extremism not just in India, but in Europe and the US as well? Why does the world have gripes with Islam, but not necessarily with Buddhism?

Fix Islam first. Fix the Middle East. Fix Pakistan extremism, which kills Hindus every day. Tackle the China Uyghur genocide.

Expand full comment

The palpable anti-Muslim hate in India as instigated by the BJP, is downright rotten. However, the Muslims cannot shirk responsibility for what is going against them. The regressive medieval show that they put on in the name of their religion and their religious and cultural artifacts cannot but invite derision in any progressive society. While BJP is legally and moralistically wrong, they are exposing the dirty underbelly of Islam that has come to haunt the western societies. Unless the depraved patriarchal culture of Islam owns up to this naked truth about them, they are but the face of Taliban in Afghanistan to all decent, non-BJP, and non-political human beings on this planet. Islamophobia is the cover under which Muslims find excuses for why they are seen as abhorrent. Step into the 21st century and smell the roses along with the rest of humanity, and you will see a world that is welcoming of the Muslims.

Expand full comment

Do not worry as these Hindu fundamentalists will pass of in no time. There are several Hindus who do not support these sort of hate. The disparity between rich and poor is widening .coupled with poverty ,unemployment and all indexes on the decline. Finally when the stomach is hit badly and hunger sets in then these same people will forget 'Jai Sri Ram etc and will revolt against the BJP bosses. You can fool the people for some time but not all the time.

Expand full comment

I didn't expect this much lies from you. Bharat mata ki jai is anti- muslim slogan? What's the connection of "Bharat mata ki jai" and anti- muslim? Actually, you playing victim card here. Before watching movie how you decided that this is anti muslim movie? And how your friends and family decided that this is anti muslim movie? The slogans were " Atankwad se azadi". Just tell me who are the Yasin malik, bitaa karate? They confessed that they killed army officers and Kashmiri pandits and it's available on YouTube and you calling them a innocents..on which basis they killed Kashmiri pandits.which slogans they have given? Just stop your victim card and be unbiased.. showing truth is anti muslim?..tumhare bar ek word me victim card dikhta hai.. Journalist to kahi dikhta hi nahi..any words for pakistan who is responsible for radicalization? Religion ke nam par behkana aur weapons kisne provide kiye the?..asman se to nahi gire honge..I expect your answer.

Expand full comment

I have watched the movie in the theatre, and did not come across any sort of this you mentioned - neither slogans nor people engaged in any such conversations. I asked several people who have watched this movie, they did not even witness any of these. You are too a special person it seems! Things happen when you are there. Might be good idea to record next time though! Considering the credibility you have in the market (I recall the financial fraud story).

The way you have made up the whole article is beyond toleration. You have good writing skill, put it for good use. Creating hatred and making a career out of it won't serve any purpose.

Expand full comment
Mar 30, 2022·edited Mar 30, 2022

It is hypocrisy when you talk about Islamophobia and don't talk about the brutal violence and ethnic cleansing of Hindus from Kashmir. You come across as an irrational person to me who constantly plays the victim card even when Islamists in Kashmir unleashed brutal violence on Hindus. The atrocities are all documented facts and yet you only cherry pick what suits your narrative. Just condemn what happened to Kashmiri Hindus unconditionally (without whataboutery, denial, deflection and distortion) and the larger society will be more receptive to your views. Only then people will see you as a balanced and logical person instead of an irrational & emotional propagandist like the very people whom you claim to fight against. Standup for all of humanity not just your religion and speak the truth. Just think why every Indian loves Dr. A.P.J. Abdul Kalam? Hindus adore him. Just think...why?

Expand full comment

""Glory to India" chant has been repeatedly weaponized against Muslims." What you and your friends in Congress (INC) smoke up these days, please write an crappy article on that too. Also please write a book " Charity Scamming for Dummies"

Expand full comment

People who blindly endorse the sympathy wave for KP should know that sometime in history the KP also created havoc and persecuted non pandits for supremacy. Please read the history below and don't be blind to extend sympathy but be rational. The movie was made keeping in view the vote bank and to reap profits. Hate for humanity is the worst form of destruction of mankind

There were three social sects of Kashmiri Pandits namely Bachabat (Priests), Jotish (Astrologers) and Karkun (Political officers of the ruling state). It is the third kind and their traitorous political misadventures that has been the root cause of the present day mess that is Kashmir.

Even during the Afghan Durrani Occupation of Kashmir, the Karkuns enjoyed political favors from the Afghans in leu of being their political officers and enforcer of their Islamic doctrines on Kashmiri Hindus. While the Afghan state selectively reorganized land grants in favors of Muslims and left Hindus Landless, the Priestly class of Kashmiri Pandits converted to Islam in mass just to get two beeghas of land to feed their family while their Karkun cousins enjoyed Afghan patronage.

Enter the Dogras in the mid 19th century, Maharaja Gulab Singh Jamwal despite being critically ill from old age and edema, reversed the land grants and redistributed it back to Hindus as first order of business and pardoned the Karkuns and let them hold their political offices in the newly established Dogra Kingdom. A trend that was followed by his successor Maharaja Ranbir Singh. The first conflict between the Kashmiri Pandits and Maharaja Ranbir arose when he started appointing Mahajans from Jammu in his officer cadre in addition to Dogra Rajputs and Kashmiri Pandits as the latter didn't enjoy sharing political levarage with other castes. By this time the Kashmiri Pandits had migrated to rest of mainland India in large droves to places like Lukhnow, Lahore and Allahbad to attain English education and hence were quite proficient in English, Urdu and Persian. The politcal elite class of Kashmiri Pandits in British India had already infilterated the press, Judicial and civil services cadre and hence started writing letters to British authority and Lobbying for sending a British presiding officer to be sent over Maharaja Ranbir Singh.

The Khair-Khawa-i-Kashmir, for example, an Urdu Magazine published from Lahore by Pt. Saligram Kaul and Pt. Hargopal Khasta were poisonous literature written to entice public opinion against Maharaja Ranbir Singh. Pt. Hargopal Kaul from Amritsar writing Ravi Benazir and Subaha Kashmir was for the same effect. Daur-uftaadagaan-i-Kashmir (period of fallen times in Kashmir) was a similar literature written by Kashmir Pandit elites from Lukhnow and Allahbad to accuse Maharaja Ranbir Singh of Misgovernence.

It was also during the times of Maharaja Ranbir Singh that Kashmiri Pandits took undue advantage of Dogras patronage towards them and openly indulged in Tax theft from the state. A particular example of that would be Dag Shawli revolt of 1865 where the Kashmiri Pandits (who owned Kashmiri Shawl production) wouldn't pay their due taxes themselves but would use wage cuts of their employees, who were mostly Muslims and Kashmiri Dalits to pay the state tax. Pt. Raj Kak Dhar was the prime accused who owed the Dogra state 12 Lakh Rupess in those times in taxes but squeezed money out of his employees instead.

All these political upheavals, revolts, mass negative propaganda gave British excuse the send a British political officer over the Maharaja but the maharaja curtailed the said officer's administrative powers in exchange of losing his choice to make his favorite son Amar Singh his heir, instead his other son Maharaja Pratap Singh took over.

Maharaja Pratap Singh was too a visionary leader and worked for the upliftment of oppressed classes of Hindus. He abolished the "Begaari system", a known form a slavery employed by Land owning Kashmiri Pandits on Kashmiri Dalits to till their land, and asked them to pay respectable wages to tillers. This further angered the KPs and they further led socialist movements against the state and printing mass propaganda against the Dogra state, for example Akhbar-i-Aam by Gwash Lal Koul from Lahore in 1925 talking about state oppression and unemployment in Kashmir to further incite public opinion against the Dogra Rulers.

It is also during this time the the elite KPs in their anti-Dogra state activities joined socialist and Communist movement to such an extent that they even opened an embassy to Soviets and colluding with Bolsheviks which directly endangered the Dogra Kingdom from British repucussions.

But the greatest brunt of the betrayal was faced by Maharaja Hari Singh when he took over. Again, like his predecessors, H.H. Hari Singh worked towards the uplifment of downtrodden classes of Hindus. He opened all state institutions like school, offices and temples to entry of Kashmiri Dalits, banned child marriage and female infanticide. Which again angered the KPs as they couldn't tolerate dalits sitting beside them eating. By this time 1931 Muslim revolt in Kashmir had happened and a young Sheikh Abdullah's popularity amongst the muslims was rising. The KPs had found their new ally against the Maharaja.

The KP elites of the valley like Kashyap Bandhu, Jiya Lal Kilam, Pt. Sudama Sidha and Prem Nath Bazaz organized under "socialist progressive" banners and allied with Shiekh Abdullah's Muslim Conference (Later named National conference) to publicly agitate and incite public opinion against the Maharaja printing and distributing Anti-dogra State literature and Manifesto named "Naya Kashmir" demanding for removal of Monarchy and establishment of democracy.

The Kashmir Socialist Party started by Prem Nath Bazaz and Kanayalal Koul too allied with the Muslim conference of Sheikh Abdullah. This party was later named All J&K Kisaan Conference in 1945, and this decision was taken after a meeting in Achabal Garden in Potohar (present day Islamabad), and Abdul Salm Yutu was made it's president.

Sheikh Abdullah with Muslim Conference and it's KP allies then launched Quit Kashmir movement against the Maharaja in 1946 which was quashed by state forces.

Parallely, Nehru in the 40s, their "Karkun" KP cousin, was lobbying with the Mainlander KP officials to put Arms Embargo on the state of J&K, convincing the Brits to stop selling the Dogra state Arms and ammunition and succeeded, and hence in 1947, a Dogra Kingdom capable of invading deep into Tibet and Freeing Lord Shiva's abode Mt. Kailasha a mere 100 years ago, capitulated under mere force of a few hundred armed non regular Afghans supported by Pak military in thousands. Maharaja Hari Singh had brave and able Dogra Rajputs and guns but no bullets to fire. Hundreds of Dogras Rajputs perished fighting with swords and limited ammos to keep machine Gun armed Pak and Afghan forces at bay while Maharaja Hari Singh sent his PM, Meherchand Mahajan, to Nehru on 19th September 1947 to sign treaty of accession. Nehru in Delhi and KPs in the valley deliberately delayed for a month for Maharaja to be pressurized into acceding to demand of making Sheikh Abdullah the first PM of newly joined J&K to the Indian union. The instrument of accession was then signed a month later on 26th October in 1947 while the Dogra Rajputs needlessly died for the greed of Sheikh Abdullah, Nehru and KP elites of the valley and India.

The biggest disservice here was also not awarding Param Veer Chakra to Brigadier Rajendra Singh of Dogra forces for his martyrdom, who was the first soldier to die for the cause of Indian Union state.

All these KPs were jeering and rejoicing to have colluded with Muslims in finally overthrowing Dogras out of power in 1951 like shameless jackals, dancing to the tune of "Kashmiriyat, Jhamooriyat, Insaaniyat" hullabaloo with their Muslim compatriots.

What did it get them? Exactly 40 years down the line, in 1991, these vermins faced worse fate than what was metted out to Dogras. Their houses burnt, their women r*ped in public, their men butchered like animals by their same allies from 40 years ago.

If one thinks that a mere movie begging for sympathy for these vermins will make them into some sorry "Hindu victim", then sorry, this proposition is a mockery of both the words "Hindu" and "victim".

Victims were those Kashmiri dalits, Laddakhi Buddhists, Dogri Rajputs, Mahajans and other hindus who are living today without a state.

Hindus were those Dogra Kings who wanted to uplift those Hindu Shudras who were being oppressed by KPs.

If one believes in Karma then the traitorous vermins who conspired against the Ma Bhagwati's Sons in a manner worse than Muslims deserved what they got. Play stupid games, win stupid prizes.

As for as popular sentimental blackmailing statement with respect to the recent movie goes "Watch this movie to see what India's future might become",

Sorry, I don't think this will be our future. Because Rajputs aren't such cowards nor Baniyas such conniving vultures nor Shudras of India such dishonorable people as these scums.

1991 Exodus is not KP legacy, karma for greed and deceit is.

The only difference between a cow and a Kashmiri Pandit is that you can't milk a cow for thirty years begging for sympathy in self styled victim-hood.

Below is a picture of what Kashmir could have been had the "Greatest Victims of the Universe" people not conspired against a Hindu state and it's Hindu subjects

Expand full comment

Hahahahhahah what a stupid article😂😂😂😂 Stop crying victim Rana! The lady next to u was using her freedom of speech. She wasn't threatening ur physical safety in any way. So much for supporting FoS, eh?

Expand full comment

Good feel humiliated and fearful so you can experience what Hindus had to deal with thanks to your islamist brothers during partition and again in bangladesh to this day. You're still privileged af compared to them and never forget it you dog.

Expand full comment

Rana how about Muslim burn train in godhra and killed 70 plus innocent Hindu .. which made you famous and you made career out of it .. seems like you career dooming now .. you can write sympathy on Mewat Muslim now to get boost at mid life carrer crisis .. I hope this bitttttttttttchget jail soon

Expand full comment

Oppression on hindus in india by radical Muslim is unbearable and against humanity. Save hindus in india

Expand full comment

Know your history before you write about retaliation in Kashmir. It was not the ordinary Muslim citizen of Kashmir who drove the Pandits out, it was terrorists that the government could not control.

Go back in history a bit more and search for what happened to the Muslims in Jammu in the genocide organised by Hindu fanatics and abetted by the then government.

Expand full comment

Samarpita when whores like you hate Hindus and Modi so much why don’t you also ignore and shut up your filthy pussy , so called liberal bitch

Expand full comment

BSDK hell to ab tumhara india mein hoga , bahut Gundagardi kar de tum haramkhoron ne

Expand full comment

@RanaAyyub Don't you think the Pseudo-Islamist agenda in India that has been running for the last 75 years is actually being demolished by Ambani / Jio and not BJP / Modi? Think, think again - something has changed after 2016 and not 2014, rationally speaking!

Expand full comment