344 Comments

When the majority of journalists have either surrendered or bowed before the regime, it is handful of journalists who are keeping afloat the flame of ethical journalism. Rana is a rare breed of courageous journalist. Truly proud of her.

Expand full comment

She gives bias reporting bro don't Fall on her trap . The world know that she is the owner of fake news factory.. and what is this new term Hindu terrorist she is using . There is no such word as hindu terrorist but for her porpagnda she using wrong term to fool you

Expand full comment

You blind Nazi Indians don’t realize what people like you, who follow your Führer Modi,

how ugly you’ve turned the once the largest democracy! What a shame!

Expand full comment

F**k the so called largest democracy tag which only makes Hindu victim and suffer in their own land. Your hate against unapologetic proud hindu is seen in your comment. And fyi the same word largest democracy has chosen Modi their prime minister because of his achievements so if you have a problem with modi why don't you contest in election and defeat him..

Expand full comment

On what basis do you make the preposterous claim:

"..largest democracy tag which only makes Hindu victim and suffer in their own land.."

?

After all, in virtually every conflagration in India, be it the Kilvenmani massacre of 1968 targeting Dalits in Tamilnadu, the Nellie massacres of 1983, the Sikh pogroms of 1984, the Bombay riots of 1992, the Gujarat pogroms of 2002, the Bhagalpur riots of 1989 & 2018 - to name a few riots and mass killings in post independence India - the victims have largely been minorities such as Muslims, Sikhs, Dalits etc.. And almost always, innocent members of these communities - usually women and children - bear the brunt of this majoritarian violence. The sad thing is that despite all this evidence, ostensibly educated Indians like you not only fall for the false propaganda emanating from the BJP IT Cell and its lumpen outfits like the Bajrang Dal, the Hindu Yuva Vahini, but also regurgitate this hate at every opportunity.

And no, I do not for a moment say that political Hinduism - Hindutva if you will - has a monopoly on violence. We have seen political violence perpetrated by Sikhs (ab)using Sikhism for violent ends in the Khalistan struggles; Muslims in Kashmir (ab)using Islam for ethnic cleansing and violence; the Shiv Sena using the "marathi manus" identity to attack South Indians, North Indians, Muslims and so on. But what I wish to point out is that under Modi and the BJP, Hinduism has been harnessed for violence and hate. Your posts being one such example that corroborates my thesis.

Expand full comment

Swiss franx my claims are based on verified facts and not half baked facts which you and your tukde tukde gang are known for using for your political means.

Truth hurts bro but that is the fact and some where in your heart you also know that hindus are being treated like foreigners and denied from their many rights in India just for minority appeasement.

Why are you not mentioning those riots and communal violence where innocent hindus were killed for no reason but just because of hate against kafirs.

Here are some quick facts for your peanut size Brain.

1998 Chamba massacre.

2002 fidayeen attacks on Raghunath temple.

2002 Akshardham Temple.

2006 Varanasi bombings.

Godhra train burning.

2003 - eight Hindus murdered by a Muslim mob in Kerala.

26/11 Mumbai terrorist attack..

Kashmiris pundit massacre.

This is just a small list from the hundreds of riots where hindus has been suffered by the jihadis in their homeland.. hindus are in majority in India but still they get killed by jihadis during riots but

You will never hear any Muslim being killed by a hindus in countries where they are in minorities.

For me you are like one of those political leaders who's life is fully dependent on Hindu bashing.

Expand full comment

Good reply but you missed so many things like the Mumbai train bombings, parliament attack, Pathankot, Pulwama and so many other terrorist attacks done on the name of Islam and Hindu hatred.

Expand full comment

Nazi is long dead come to your senses and love your country and the people of the country...

Expand full comment

The RSS is a product of Hitler's Nazism and Mussolini's fascism. Its fascist, racist ideology called Hindutva courses through the veins of the BJP.

No Sir, Indian Nazism is alive and well. Indeed, Hitler's Mein Kampf is a very popular read in India.

Expand full comment

Ohh is that true my friend. I hate Nazi they were really cruel people they have killed millions of innocent Jews..

I only know good things about india I didnt know that BJP is so cruel. Which religion BJP follows Let me guess it must be islam because most of the hate is present in Arab faith the Indian faith is all about love and kindness against all beings. Can you tell me more about this new terrorist group in India know as hindutava please..Actually islam is a good religion but some people like BJP , ISIS and other terrorist group are using it for their selfish means .. the quran has many good teachings but these people are misinterpreteing it for their political means...so don't blame any religion for it my friend.. I'm a Hindu but I respect islam as I respect my faith.. but the recent killing of hindoo in India and destroying of temples is really sad. our iskcon temple was destroyed and devotee got killed and the world is not doing much why are our lives not matters.. we had a Large protest in Guanya and wrote to Bangladesh authorities they say culprits will be punished but how long it will take we want justice now.. justice for partha Das

Expand full comment

Who’s this joker!!!

Expand full comment

Ashley Cooper calm down bitch and suck some Mullah ISIS dick , you need that desperately otherwise get Gang bang by Muslims they are known for rape 😂

Expand full comment

Well said Mr/Ms Ashley Cooper!

The problem in India though is that people want to replace democracy by Führer Modi's thinly veiled Nazism. And his legions of crazed, venom spewing, lumpen goons from the North of India will die for this cult leader.

Meanwhile, smart Indians, including the Gujaratis who once propped up Modi are slowly moving their assets abroad to offshore centres. Soon, Indians will only have Hindutva to eat. And the amazing thing is that this takes place through the ballot box - aided and abetted by the flaws of the First Past the Post electoral system that India inherited from the British.

Expand full comment

Modi is a bad man but you are also bad man you want hindoos to divided and fight no good my friend.. Krishna temple destyr in Bangladesh you have to pay for it here and after death. Partha Das good devotee killed in temple pond we feel sad and cry for hindoos in Bangladesh india.

Expand full comment

Maivada:

Violence against Hindus in Islamic countries like Pakistan and Bangladesh is terrible. No questions asked.

But does Islamist violence against minorities in these countries violence against Hindus justify Hindutva violence against Muslims in India? And since when did Pakistan become a role model for India?

Expand full comment

Thank you my friend for condemning the violence in this Islamic countries against my community.

No brother no violence can be justified . sorry I don't much about hindutava but from you I can understand that hindutava are really terrible people.

Hindus are very peace full community you should work together with hindus and defeat hindutava BJP. Throw hindutava out from India . india should become a role model for all other countries.. Indias role model should be great saint who preached peace like buddha and not terrorist like Osama bin laden Pakistani...

Expand full comment

Hindu terror is alive and well - jsut ask the family of the many innocent Muslims who get lynched by your Hindutva friends.

Expand full comment

swiss franx me and you know this is very well that India is the most safest place to live for Muslim and other minorities . If you don't agree you should compare the life of hindus in Islamic nation with life of muslim in India. And as a matter of fact Muslims are enjoying greater freedom in India then the so called Muslim countries around the world.

And why are you turning blind eye on the attrocties carried against minorities in Islamic countries. Show some bravery and speak about them to if not for minorities then for your own ummnah because you know very well that Muslims are the biggest victim of Islamic terrorism in this so called Muslim countries..

And I don't get it ,what hindutava Terrorism you are talking about can you tell me atlest one united Nation designated terrorist group that belongs to hindus . Also which religion group uses young children for suicide attacks. Ok forget about this let's discuss about India can you tell me one Hindu terrorist group in India which is banned domestically and internationally.

Expand full comment

Fully agree on your points.. villi are you a she or he..

Expand full comment

Thanks for the reply Vili.

You pontificate:

".. India is the most safest place to live for Muslim and other minorities .."

Well, try telling that to the many innocent Muslims who get lynched by your Hindutva buddies. Try telling that to the families of Mohammad Akhlaq, Junaid Khan, Pehlu Khan, Tabrez Ansari, Mohammad Afrazul, Alimuddin Ansari and many many others.

In the lynching of 30 year old Musharaff in Delhi, the poor man was dragged out of his house by a mob of Hindus, taken out to the street and beaten to death. All in front of his 11 year old daughter Kushi who pleaded with the attackers to spare her dad. To no avail. I do not wish that fate upon any human being Vili - nobody should watch a loved one getting butchered the way this poor man was killed.

What is worse, in India, your thuggish friends who kill Muslims get garlanded and even given sweets when they are let out on bail. Indeed, Minister Jayant Sinha did exactly that to the murderers of Alimudding Ansari.

Welcome to Incredible India - err Lynchistan.

Expand full comment

Manhh what a stone hearted person you are . You only consider Muslim as victims what about Kashmiri pundits and hindus who are being killed in other parts of India.

You seem like a educated person please think wisely . In India the muslim population is more than 213 millions the unfortunate incidents that you are mentioning above is not even 0.01% of the Muslim population in India. Tell me one country around the world which is totally crime free , stop leaving in your Dreamland this are smaller incidents which does not represents Hindunism or india.

And also just recently two sadhus were brutality murdered in temple by 2 extremist Muslim youths but there was no media outrage because the victim was not from a minority community. You see this are all double standard by media when hindus are victim no one cares.

Also read this, which is taken from economic times.

" The five accused Salman, Nadeem, Shahzad, Najeem and Jabbar were arrested .....“The accused say Lajja Ram’s tongue was also chopped off by them as a signal to people who complain against cow smuggling,” ...

I haven't seen rana ayub talking about this incidents neither any one from the muslim community..

If you want all this hate violence to be stopped then you should ask your own self Why all over the world muslim are being targeted..

if you change your thinking and embrace love and leave this kafir hate things then brother the world would be in peace..

Expand full comment

Great reply bro👏👏 no one in the media establishment cares about Hindu lives. Rana Ayyub doesn't care. You're absolutely right about everything

Expand full comment

My sympathy for the victims of all those who gets lynch . Only through love we can conquer hate . Muslim are good people they are nice and carring only the politician and journalist and Muslim preachers misguide this muslim youths for own benefits..

Expand full comment

How come you never criticize those muslim nations who are committing non stop atrocities against innocent minorities ???? Can't you see how bad hindus are treated in Pakistan, Afghanistan and Bangladesh..

Expand full comment

We are talking about Democratic India not some Islamic or other countries.

Expand full comment

Swiss bank those who are killed are victims and has no mention in Hindu culture. The world is full of Good people only certain group of people makes it look bad but this is not acceptable in any religion.. your brother me no hate you if you cut our hands same color blood me and you.. hindu and Muslim and Christians all brothers we worship same god in different ways..

Expand full comment

Maivada:

I don't grasp what you write - my English is not that good you see...

Expand full comment

No worries friend it is understandable but if you want you can improve your English from reading English books . Hope it helps you..

Expand full comment

You didn't get my sarcasm did you Sir ?

Expand full comment

pathetic of you

Expand full comment

Shame on you .

Expand full comment

Eda mat ban peda nahin milega!!

Expand full comment

Sibghaut ulla soory i did not get what you are saying.. if you speak in Indian local language I will reply france..

LInde est geniale uniquement parce qu'elle est a majorite hindu, ne me croyez pas, allez passer votre journee dans n'importe quel pays muslim et comparez cela avec India..

Expand full comment

katua

Expand full comment

👍👍👍

Expand full comment

What a joke 😄😄😄

Expand full comment

India is in an advanced state of Genocide. It is happening, some in broad daylight, others behind the scene. Very factual article exposing the Hindutva tribe.

Expand full comment

Haha 😂😂 you guys are trying hard to make India Islamic state keeping trying it will never happen hindus are getting united then there were ever before.

Expand full comment

Don't make india hindoo or Islam keep it Gandhi secular..

Expand full comment

Oh vili..it’s quite clear you have made a career out of hating Muslims. You seem to be the most vocal on this thread and your approach towards every argument is reflective of anger and hate. The problem is it’s very easy to hate on the internet while you sit in your office or home on a computer and don’t even dare to share your full name. The unfortunate part villi is that when this hate will create a genocide on the streets of India people like you and me will suffer. We will all Hindus, Muslims, Christians huddle under our beds with crying children while we hear screams and sticks outside our windows. The journalists will be issued diplomatic passports overnight and will leave the country, the affluent are already organising foreign nationalities for themselves (our very own Akshay Kumar is a Canadian now did you know?) and the politicians will have hundred of police and barricades outside their residences but it will be people like you and me who’s businesses, families and children will all die a slow death. So kudos to you keep doing what your doing and burn the middle class to the ground.

Expand full comment

shweta ji can you please tell me who creates this hate in our society. Maybe you feel okay when innocent hindus are killed by jihadis for no reason but I can't because they are my brothers and sisters.

All over the world jihadis are creating problem for non muslim faiths community .give me one good reason why a person should accept this jihadis as their family and not hate them ..how can I say Muslim are my brothers when they always keep on making fun of our culture and killing our people. How can we love monsters who are working day and night to devide India . And please note I'm not talking about good moderate Muslims here I'm talking about jihadis who unfortunately gets inspired from Quran.

Expand full comment

Those who get inspired for terrorism are not Muslim or followers of islam they are extremists ..

Expand full comment

You are talking about a specific group of people who should definitely be held accountable for crimes that they commit. How can you generalise an entire religion and an entire community based on what a specific group of people do? That’s like saying sati is performed till today in most hindu communities in villages. Till today there are hindu fathers who get their daughters married at the age of 11 and 12 in remote parts of India. Does that mean the entire religion of Hinduism should be judged based on these few people who still commit these crimes?

Expand full comment

Why you concerned about hindoos India but not those in Bangladesh . Our iskcon temple destroyed devotees killed please show some kind to them ..

Expand full comment

I can feel your pain bro, but rest be assured we are all with you in your time of grief.

I cannot even imagine the pain and suffering the hindus in Bangladesh must be going through. May Lord Ram makes it easy and gives you strength to bear the loss of a great young devotee.

I think you are from Iskcon am I right bro??

I'm a born sanatani Hindu but my girl friend and her family are all from iskcon community... stay blessed and regards to the hindu and iskcon community in Guanya..

Expand full comment

You are trying to make career by licking muslims.

Expand full comment

India has been a fascist state under this chap Modi. This is coming from a Hindu Brahmin . There is a genocide in making something on the scale that we haven't seen.

The masses has been radicalised beyond limit.

Expand full comment

Do you even know the meaning of fascist?

Expand full comment

Brother don't get fooled by his Hindu name he is one of the madarasa chap with fake name.. just read some of his comments and you will know how much hate he has for hindus and Hindu scriptures.

Brother sudip get a life manh you won't achieve anything with this..

Expand full comment

Fascist is like racist

Expand full comment

Well, I've a post graduation degree in Physical science from IIT Hyderabad and have written the prestigious Civil Services Mains examination twice in 2019 and 2020.

What do you expect out of people ? To crack some joke on Fascism and it's juggernauts w/o even meaning it.😂😂

Expand full comment

Toh pagal IIT mein engineering padne jata hai ki social studies. Agar itna he fascism fascism karna hai toh JNU jaana chahiye tha aur activist banta. Kuch saalo baad aise articles likhta, paise kamata. Jaaye ko seat waste kari tuney ??

Expand full comment

Hahahaha, first achieve something in your life and then blabber like this.

People like you don't deserve reply from me given the fact your brain is still filled with cow's shit. Just get lost

Expand full comment

India is the birth place of dhramic religion and yoga it can be a fascist State because lord Buddha choose India for awakened and not other country.. India is a holy and blessed country..

Expand full comment

Lol coming from a Hindu Brahmin haha. just having a fake hindu name does not make you hindu forgot about being bhramin.

Expand full comment

This divisive tactics won't work with me, chap.

Try this crap with people like yours ,not with me.

You are none to classify someone as Hindu /Brahmin for that matter. You are an exaggerated piece of extremist, nothing else 😀

Expand full comment

Brother remove this false pride from you.. you are saying you are an educated person but you sound so illiterate to me.. I have also received many prizes in my school days but I'm not from those who will boost about his own self. What is the bharmmin and hindu you are taking about do you know their actual meaning.

You can't call yourself self bharmain unless you process certain qualities . There is no where in scriptures it is mentioned that you become bhramin from birth.. in Bhagavad Gita the lord kirshna clearly explains who is bhramin and who is not please read it..in short, Just like you have to study and do your degree to be called IT technician likewise you have to study Scriptures to be accepted as bhrahman. In other words a son of a doctor cannot automatically become a doctor. Though there are better chances that he can become a doctor, unless he becomes a doctor he cannot be accepted as such. On the other hand, even the son of a farmer can become a doctor provided he has got that qualification. Similarly one cannot automatically become a brahmana because one is born in a brahmana family. He can be accepted as a brahmana if he meets all the brahminical qualifications. On the other hand, if the brahminical qualifications are found in the person of a sudra, he should immediately be accepted as a brahmana. To substantiate this there are many quotations from Bhagavatam, Mahabharata, Bharadvaja-samhita and the pancharatra, as well as many other sscriptures.

Brahman is also called the brahma-jyoti, or spiritual light because they are the ones who educates the society. So your called bharmin tagline means nothing if you are quite and silently witnesing the atrocities carring out against your own community.

Expand full comment

Tell this Manusmriti things to your son and relatives,man. You're a brainwashed, dickhead bhakt who have been told that Hindus are in danger in this country.

I don't have time and energy to get involved with absolute lunatic like you. 😂

Expand full comment

Haha, you just proved that you were pretending to be bhramin and hindu but actually you are one of the madarasa chap.. nice try bro..

There is no where in my comments I have mentioned about manusimriti, haha you madarasa chap don't know what is Gita atlest learn some basis of Hindunism then pretend to be hindu.

Good try though.

Expand full comment

Your attempt at sounding like a modern person simply disgusts me,man

You pass on judgments no person having such achievements in life will have. You emotion-driven reply is contrary to the fact that you attempted civil services. A wise and befitting reply never crushes the adversary,it rather wins him over and this tactic can only be used by highly skilled people. Ergo,i request you to please learn the meaning of being a real,justified,mature man before passing judgements over someone,before calling anyone a dickhead.

Expand full comment

Sudip Sherma what kind of Hindoo you are . just having hindoo name is not enough stop this believe that Hindu is not a religion but way of life.. hindu are sanatani we worship supreme god Krishna .

Expand full comment

Only fascist minds like Rana Ayyub can think of India being a fascist state. Shame on Ayyub's style of journalism with no objectivity and ethics. Read my article for more: https://www.pgurus.com/rana-ayyubs-journalistic-ethics-and-anti-india-anti-modi-innuendos-in-washington-post/

Expand full comment

Dear Vijendra, Rana’s piece is her opinion and analysis of events in the course of a year none of which can be disputed. She has not named fictional characters who have been killed with photoshopped photographs or fictional characters in imaginary jails. Your piece predominantly centers around Rana’s intention, her approach and her style which are all speculative and not factual from any angle. Please let’s not play the Modi is a tea seller card anymore. Putin also came from humble beginnings so did most dictators. I am a gujarati Hindu woman but first I am a mother and we don’t support leaders who look the other way when women and children are being stabbed and raped so spare us the Modi is a good man speech.

Expand full comment

Thank you for speaking and defending the voice of those unfortunately privileged due to Modi's reign.

Expand full comment

Very well written Ms Shweta Shah. I truly admire your calm, composed and yet hard-hitting rebuttals of the venom thrown here by the Hindutva crowd.

Please do write often. You might also want to read some of my posts here - I recently joined the blog.

Expand full comment

Seems like a major threat in India is hindutava you people have to work as a one and teach this hindutava jihadis a lesson which they will never forget.. and why this jihadis using the term hindutava for terror attacks in India it sounds to familler with Hindunism.. the Muslim only working day and night to destroy India but don't let hindutava to achieve this..

Expand full comment

I don't agree with your observation, there are lot of fake events mentioned giving only one perspective without looking at actual facts

Expand full comment

None of the incidents Rana mentioned are fake. They are all verified by multiple newspapers some international as well that have a thorough fact checking system that relies on minimum two sources. If you are claiming that they are fake events you must have proof to back that claim with a counter source.

Expand full comment

Ms Ayyub's statements are accurate. Indeed, they corroborate what most European media have observed from India. But then, Indians are consumers of paid media aren't they ? And the BJP controls the press ... in India, journalists get hounded and served with murder and rape threats if you don't toe the government line don't they ? And the murder and rape threats that Ms Ayyub faces prove that democracy under Modi is evaporating and a saffron fascism is replacing it. Ironically, aided and abetted by its own Hindu citizens. Citizens like you who would rather worship a semi-literate, incompetent, callous man with a pogrom under his belt rather than speak truth to power as Ms Ayyub does.

Expand full comment

Can your bigoted gobar infested sanghi ass deny even a single incident quoted in this article.? You won't be able to. Your kind are not used to factual reporting.

Expand full comment

So so so many lies in this article. Here are just a few:

Lie number 1: She calls Nathuram Gods a terrorist. This is false. He was an assissin. There's a difference.

Lie number 2: "discriminatory Citizenship bill and the National register of Citizens that seeks proof of nationality from its Muslim population" The CAA has nothing to do with Indian muslims. It is for granting citizenship to persecuted minorities from 3 neighbouring muslim countries. The NRC hasn't even been drafted yet, and it is supposed to make a list of legal citizens in India, both muslim and otherwise. It's not like it'll only question indian muslims or something. What a shameless liar🙄

Lie number 3: "Kapil Mishra held a rally where they gave incendiary speeches against traitors and anti-nationalists (by which they clearly meant Indian Muslims)" How do u know?????? How do u know he meant only and all Indian muslims?????? Rana has no evidence

Lie number 4: "anti Muslim riot" WRONG!! The Delhi riots on the 24th were clearly anti-Hindu in nature. Molotov cocktails were found on the terrace of Tahir Hussain. He and other muslims present shouted "Maro Kaafiro ko!" before gutting Hindus. A constable(Hindu) was killed. IB officer Ankit Sharma's body was mutilated and thrown in the gutter. Dilbar Negi's body was burned. According to confessions of Tahir hussain himself and a number of muslims with him, they planned the riots a long time back b4 they happened. This is all documented in the chargesheets filed by Delhi police. Also well compiled by OpIndia, which did a great job covering the riots.

Lie number 5: "Assam, where thousands of Muslims are being expelled from their homes of their forefathers?" Nope!! They were illegal Bangladeshis who were illegally squatting on Indian land. That's y they were removed

Hope this helps u 😊

Expand full comment

@Dargon Le monde se tait lorsque les hindus sont victims. Et que dire a ces soi-disant hindus qui sont temoins en silence des atrocities commises contre l'humanite, ils sont des laches et n'ont aucun respect pour les leurs.

Certains hindous en India se soucient trop de leurs references liberals laiques.

🙏🙏🙏🙏

Expand full comment

I agree with what you have said bro. Don't worry too much India is changing now. Just keep fighting the good fight👊 We will prevail against jihadi Islamist forces. Jai Shri Krishna🙏🙏

Expand full comment

Thank you dargon Mr or Ms. Very good facts .. please do something for Bangladesh hindoos they suffering there make your Indian government to speak .

Expand full comment

I think my government has gone soft lately😞. But we will keep pressurizing them on social media. Be well, friend.

Expand full comment

Thank you dargon this means a lot. We

Guyanese hindus has lots of hope in in Indian government.. if your government is so scared to speek against my iskcon hindu community in Bangladesh then throw this politicians in dust bin.. I lost all my senses seeing how our young devotee partha Das was murdered in temple pond.. this is kaliyugaa demons are very dangerous.

Expand full comment

It's only a matter of time before Yogi Adityanath ji comes into power in the centre♥️ he is not so light on these Jihadis. He knows how to take tough actions. Jai Shri Ram to you!🙏

Expand full comment

Dragon:

You pontificate:

"..They were illegal Bangladeshis who were illegally squatting on Indian land .."

Let us look at the state of affairs in Modistan Dragon. In India, if someone simply sends a letter to the Indian government under some fictitious name stating that you and your parents are illegal Muslims masquerading under Hindu names, that would be more than enough for the government of Modistan to first arrest you, take you to the nearest police post, thrash you, abuse you, insult you and then if you are alive, they may ask you questions. The burden of responsibility to prove that you are a Hindu is now yours. Unlike in other democracies where rule of law is supreme, the accuser viz. the government does not have to prove its allegations, the accused has to. That is Modistan for you.

Indeed, in Assam, 1 single name - Debajit Goswami - appears in hundreds of letters denouncing the citizenship claims of poor, illiterate Muslims in the state, see ref: econ.st/2XKSaSX . In fact, this mysterious Debajit Goswami does not exist and does not live in his registered address - he was merely a fictitious character created to throw Muslims out of the country. Some 220,000 such letters denouncing Muslim residents were sent to the citizenship Tribunals. Needless to say, the onus of providing the documentation is on the many thousand accused, not the accusers or the government which trusts anyone who denounces Muslims.

In a country where the majority of the people do not have birth, marriage and death certificates, passports, proper title deeds and so on, it is willy-nilly impossible to produce these. After all, even Prophet Modi has been unable to produce papers to the effect that he is a graduate of Delhi University hasn't he?

The irony of all this is that even decorated Muslim soldiers who have served the Indian Armed Forces get thrown into Modi's concentration camps because they don't have papers. Mohammad Sanaullah who served the country for more than 30 years, fought in Kargil, was denounced by 3 "witnesses" who claimed he was not an Indian ad promptly put into a concentration camp, see ref: bbc.in/3CeeGTe . His story leaked out, became an embarassment for the government and he was ordered to be released by the Supreme Court. Later investigatons revealed that his alleged accusers never had given any statements about the soldier.

Dragon: Each of your preposterous, puerile and pathetic claims can be taken apart like the last one that I did. I suggest you run back to your mentors in the Hindu Yuva Vahini or the Bajrang Dal or the Hindu Sena or whichever lumpen, lathi wielding you belong to and ask them to assign a job more appropraite to your intellectual level. Clearly, you supply enought proof to conclusively demonstrate that don't belong here in these columns.

Expand full comment

Great response.. keep it up Swiss bank

Expand full comment

Dear Swiss,

Your skill at building up a strawman is as effective as Rana's pitiful attempts to smear Modi's administration i.e. feeble. "where thousands of Muslims are being expelled" is what her words were. You proceeded to list only a couple examples of errors committed by the government, that too by non-Indian publications, both of which have a enormous history of writing fake news about affairs in their own country, let alone those in foreign ones like India. All the fake news and smearing of the brave Tommy Robinson of Luton would be a terrific example.

Let me give you an *Indian* source, with impeccable history, which talks about the barbaric nature of the Muslim Bangladeshi squatters who were living on government owned land, see ref: https://www.opindia.com/2021/09/watch-thousands-attacked-assam-police-evict-illegal-bangladeshi-5000-shiva-temple-stands/

👆This specific incident is what Rana Ayyub talks about in her miserable excuse for an article. However, filled with ignorance, you went on to rant about some flaws made by the government many months prior to this episode, thereby wasting your time, and more importantly, mine.

I surf the comment sections of pathetic columns like this seeking peaceful, insightful and respectful debate which stimulates intellect. Your inability to be insightful, or be intellectually stimulating, is distinctly manifest. As for me, I look forward to joining the magnanimous RSS in the near future, and be part of some of the magnificent work they perform. I suggest you go on and make an attempt to "take apart" my points that comprehensively dismember Rana's numerous falsehoods. Please don't commit logical fallacies this time, or I will be dissuaded to reply to or indeed, read the full comment of a narcissistic, moronic, infantile, asinine excuse for an human being above 12 years of age. Here's wishing you a good day.

Expand full comment

Swiss Franx talks sense. Opindia is not in the business of journalism but stoking and fomenting violence against vulnerable minorities by publishing canards. Opindia is nothing but a sort of Facebook for Fascism. And Hindutva, which has essentially copied the fascist movements of Europe of the 1930s is the RSS version of this hideous, violent ideology.

Swiss Franx, through his many well crafted, well argued posts - in excellent English - clearly draws the distinction between Hinduism the noble religion and Hindutva, the fascist political ideology that the RSS and BJP spread in India and abroad. The unity of India is at stake here - after all no more than 37.5% of Indians voted for the BJP and its nativist, Hindi belt, upper caste centric take on fascism.

Expand full comment

Really?? When has Opindia ever advocated for violence against minorities????? Can u give me a single☝example????

Yeah, it was Hindutva that imposed the 2 yr emergency on India and jailed poets, journalists and political dissenters, wasn't it? Oh no wait, that was the Congress Party, one of Hindutva's biggest opponents🙄🙄 It was Hindutva that advocated for a jail term for hurting one's religious sentiments through speech, which dented a hole in India's laws regarding free speech and freedom of expression, wasn't it? Oh wait no, that was Islamists who wanted that cause they were too butthurt over comments mocking their "precious" prophet. It was Hindutva that cut the hands of a Christian teacher that allegedly spoke against the Islamic prophet, wasn't it. Oh no wait, that was actually a gang of members of the Islamist organization PFI. Please bro, don't embarrass yourself this way.

I don't see what him having excellent English has to do with anything🤔🤔 India today is more united than ever b4 BECAUSE of the efforts of the Hindutva movement. "upper caste?" Do u think Narendra Modi and Yogi Adityanath are upper caste?? They're actually both Dalits. There are more Dalits than ever b4 in the cabinet under BJP. Also, Dalits are increasingly voting for BJP like nothing b4. "Hindi belt?" Oh Karnataka, Maharashtra, Jammu, Ladhak, Nagaland and Assam come under the Hindi Belt don't they?🙄🙄What a dolt.

Right. 353 seats out of 543 in the Lok Sabha is 37.5% right?🙄 Clearly, Hindutva has brought India closer together like nothing b4, and will continue to do so.

Expand full comment

Dragon:

You raise several points. But let me stick to your preference for the rag Opindia. OpIndia makes utterly no efforts to shield the fact that it is a mouthpiece of the ruling BJP. OpIndia is an unabashedly right wing and spouts nothing but Hindutva propaganda, Modi worship and aims to further the agendas of thuggish outfits like the RSS.

Ironically, Opindia claims to indulge in fact checking and applied for recognition as a member of the International Fact Checking Network (IFCN) and was summarily rejected. Here is the damning verdict that IFCN had when throwing out OpIndia:

"Though the fact checks cover a variety of subjects, they do concentrate on a certain political organization or organizations with a certain ideology. Of the ten fact-checks given (by OpIndia) as examples, nearly all are focused on trying to disprove information put out by a certain political party or by organizations that are seemingly inclined toward that political party. Or, have writing that indicates that an opposition party is either behind it or is taking advantage of it. Its method in reaching or presenting its conclusions presents evidence of potential bias. .. Also, in the page where the website invites contributions from readers, it clearly indicates its bias. I quote from the website: “We won’t entertain the usual left-liberal narrative”.

So your claim:

"Let me give you an *Indian* source, with impeccable history"

falls flat on its face.

In the meantime, you may entertain yourself by reading articles such as this in Opindia:

"Haryana: Pregnant goat dies after being gangraped by eight men, Haroon and Jaffar amongst accused" bit.ly/3pFIQet

Expand full comment

Awwww swiss. You broke my heart bro😢 it's been 4 days and you still haven't responded citing a single instance of fake news by opindia. You seemed so confident. Sad..

Expand full comment

Swiss:

Neither me, nor Opindia nor its readers give 2 hoots about the opinions of international organizations, which have a solid history of lying through their teeth time and time again about India.

Nope! It doesn't fall flat on its face at all. Opindia has an impeccable record. Why don't we analyze it via first principles. Instead of regurgitating the speech of some hardly relevant entity, why don't you go ahead and list a single, I repeat, a SINGLE piece that Opindia has ever published that has been a lie or even a misdirection? Go on and show me just one ☝ such piece and I will humbly beg a thousand times for your forgiveness.

It is beyond disgusting that you would think that something like that would "entertain" me. Btw Opindia has cited sources inside that piece. If you cared to read it, you would know that one of them is My Nation, see ref:https://hindi.mynation.com/news/goat-s-dead-after-gang-rape-in-haryana-s-mewat-pcj26s

The remarkable thing about Opindia is that it doesn't hide behind the veil of neutrality, unlike "journalists" like Rana Ayyub, who do so and proceed to spew lies and venom against Hindus, whilst conveniently forgetting to list out the numerous crimes of the members of her "Ummah". The writers of Opindia aren't hypocrites. They are HONEST journalists, and honesty is arguably the paramount quality of a competent journalist. I have proudly donated to Opindia numerous times, and I will be making yet another humble contribution to them in response to Rana's pathetic piece.

Looking forward to your reply, Swiss. Don't let me down now.😜😜

Expand full comment

Mr Vijendra Agarwal:

Rather than hurl abuses at Ms Ayyub, why don't you refute her arguments ? Clearly, you are incapable of doing that and merely resort to name calling Ms Ayyub, the Washington Post and and so on. 

India is rapidly turning into a fascist state and Ms Ayyub is not the only one confirming that. Here are some independent research institutes that state more or less what Ms Ayyb says.

1. The Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) ranks India at 53 and India a "flawed democracy". ref: bit.ly/3Gxaror

2. Gøteborg, Sweden based based V-Dem ranks India at an abysmal 91 and terms India as "autocratising", ref: bit.ly/30Rc7bI

3. US based Freedom House calls India "partly free ". It divides countries into "free", "partly free" and "not free",  ref: bit.ly/3jAQq6v

Now Mr Agarwal, you have more institutions to hurl invectives upon. You can now prove to your saffron friends in the Bajrang Dal, Hindu Yuva Vahini, RSS etc. what a great Hindu - pardon - Hindutvaist - you are !!  Godse, Babu Bajrangi, Pramod Muthalik, Praveen Tagodia  etc. would be proud of a great Hindu like you Sir ! 

Incidentally, even TIME writes about Ms Ayyub and I am yet to see you attack TIME ! And lest I forget, France's Le Monde also praises Ms Ayyub. You need to thrash Le Monde too Mr Agarwal !! But I guess your ability to hurl abuses in French are a tad limited aren't they Sir?

Allow me to remind you Sir of a quote from Napoléon Bonaparte which sums up your predicament:

"Four hostile newspapers are more to be feared than a thousand bayonets"

Mr Agarwal: I must conclude that you and your lumpen Hindutva friends are truly scared of a frail young Muslim woman who, like the late Ms Gauri Lankesh (RIP) has the balls to speak truth to power. And they use a pen, not a sword.

Expand full comment

There seem to be no made up stories. Its mere facts. You are bashing her on personal terms. Its like if i tell u stick to Physics

Expand full comment

I am sorry your observation is wrong , there are many incorrect narratives to drive one's main propaganda for hate for one person

Expand full comment

pk:

Do you expect that in a civilized society that we call it today, for any right-thinking person to develop love for the head of a state, who deliberately maintains a deafening silence when the son of one of his "bahubali" ministerial colleagues crushes the protesting farmers by his Jeep catching them unaware, instead of removing him from the cabinet immediately?

Expand full comment

DragonOct 22

So so so many lies in this article. Here are just a few:

Lie number 1: She calls Nathuram Gods a terrorist. This is false. He was an assissin. There's a difference.

Lie number 2: "discriminatory Citizenship bill and the National register of Citizens that seeks proof of nationality from its Muslim population" The CAA has nothing to do with Indian muslims. It is for granting citizenship to persecuted minorities from 3 neighbouring muslim countries. The NRC hasn't even been drafted yet, and it is supposed to make a list of legal citizens in India, both muslim and otherwise. It's not like it'll only question indian muslims or something. What a shameless liar🙄

Lie number 3: "Kapil Mishra held a rally where they gave incendiary speeches against traitors and anti-nationalists (by which they clearly meant Indian Muslims)" How do u know?????? How do u know he meant only and all Indian muslims?????? Rana has no evidence

Lie number 4: "anti Muslim riot" WRONG!! The Delhi riots on the 24th were clearly anti-Hindu in nature. Molotov cocktails were found on the terrace of Tahir Hussain. He and other muslims present shouted "Maro Kaafiro ko!" before gutting Hindus. A constable(Hindu) was killed. IB officer Ankit Sharma's body was mutilated and thrown in the gutter. Dilbar Negi's body was burned. According to confessions of Tahir hussain himself and a number of muslims with him, they planned the riots a long time back b4 they happened. This is all documented in the chargesheets filed by Delhi police. Also well compiled by OpIndia, which did a great job covering the riots.

Lie number 5: "Assam, where thousands of Muslims are being expelled from their homes of their forefathers?" Nope!! They were illegal Bangladeshis who were illegally squatting on Indian land. That's y they were removed

Expand full comment

Claustrophobia you talked about is so real. As a youth of this country, it can get very scary and lonely seeing the rampant hate-mongering by govt. Leaders like you really give us strength and hope to hold onto in these very dark times. Even writing this comment is giving me a mild anxiety attack. I wish we didn't have to live through this cruelty.

Expand full comment

That is the sad state of affairs in Modistan today Mr/Ms Tish.

I understand that you are anxious to speak up. One must not forget that journalists in Modistan have a target on their backs. If you are too big and famous, they will hound you and threaten you with rape and murder. Journalist Gauri Lankesh was murdered in cold blood and her killers were willing to do it for a paltry Rs 10,000. If you are less famous and simply comment in these columns and speak truth to power, bhakths like Vili, Vijendra Agarwal, Sridhar etc. will descend upon you with their Hindutva inspired jingoism and call you names.

Debate in Modistan has simply degenerated to disagreeable behaviour and puerile name calling.

Expand full comment

Among RARE Species of Journalist with SPINE❤❤

Expand full comment

Mr or Ms 0_0 she is not a good journalist I never saw her speaking on the recent riots in Bangladesh which destroyed and killed hindoo.. if hindoo outside of India are fighting for justice then why you are silent..

Expand full comment

I hope that what you have written is an exaggeration. There are many millions of Indians like me who are deeply secular. We believe in the equality of man, equality of religion. This flirtation with RW nationalism is I hope, a phase which will end by 2024 when people realise that Ram Mandir will not fill their bellies. It's all about the economy, jobs and opportunities matter more than enforcing majoritarianism. This is my hope and belief.

Expand full comment

Many of us voted for the fake promise by the pseudo nationalist communal hate mongering leaders just to be led away in the abyss of communal hate, fear psychosis and loss of lives. 7 years and still hindu khatre mein but no one NO ONE cares about the economy, jobs or lower taxes. Damn not even abt $ at 40, Petrol at 30 and Tax bracket going down by at least 50%. all farce

Expand full comment

Very well said Velah Indian !

Fact is, Modi's financiers and the vast network of Gujarati businessmen have quietly moved their funds away from India and into offshore accounts. Meanwhile, the only readily available job seems to be that of a gaurakshak where you can run around and extort poor Muslims - whilst not killing them.

But the North Indian inhabitants of Lynchistan don't see - yet - the hunger and joblessness that is the only outcome of Modi's Hindutva. And lest I forget, they also get a Ram Mandir and praying there will magically produce jobs and chappathis on the table !

Expand full comment

India is a natural home land for hindus all over the world.. India should have similar laws like isreal which makes Jews from anywhere to return back to their land. Secular is good but not too much that makes you foregt your own culture and roots..

Expand full comment

I loved your sane, sober comment Mr Madhusudhan Sikri. And I sincerely hope that your prayers will come true. Alas, I am not that optimistic - given trends in Indian and in many other parts of the world, including the so called mature democracies like the US, UK and other places like the Philippines, Indonesia etc.

Sadly, identity based on religion, race, ethnicity, denominations within religions, language etc. have been skilfully exploited by demagogues and dangerous nationalists like Modi, Trump, Duterte etc. to grab power by convincing voters that as long as someone stood for their identity, everything else did not matter. Thus we had the curious spectacle of American workers who were actually dependent on Obamacare for their medical expenses voting for Trump who promised to dismantle it; we have seen poor, white American voters voting for Trump despite evidence to the effect that his policies prioritised his coterie of rich friends; we have seen Indians voting for the very man - Modi - who oorchestrated a pogrom and sent the economy into a tailspin with his patently foolish idea called demonetisation; we have seen Indian voters extolling the virtues of Modi despite the thrashing India gets from an aggressive China; we have seen Indian voters praising Modi despite his diverting scarce funds during the pandemic to build a palace for himself and so on.

The secularism you mention has now met its ignoble "sati" at the hands of the Hindutva mobs who control the narrative and believe in throwing innocent Muslims on the funeral pyre as well. And soon democracy will also get its sati. Mind you, with the connivance of the many Hindu voters who strongly believe that a man who tacitly encourages pogroms or the lynchings of innocent Muslims is the Messiah who must lead India. Just take a look at some of the replies to the comments of Ms Shweta Singh and myself.

The Greek philosopher Plato once said:

"The people always have some champion whom they set over them and nurse into greatness. This and no other is the root from which a tyrant springs; when he first appears he is a protector "

Applies certainly to Modi.

Expand full comment

Show some of your love for Bangladesh hindoos they are suffering and killed for no reason then I know you man..haree Krishna

Expand full comment

Thank you, Swiss. I have just read many of the comments here and am shocked by a few. One is the justification of the terrorist / assassin Godse. Second is the constant reference to 800 years of Muslim domination in parts of the subcontinent, first by Central Asian raiders then by Indian Muslim rulers. How can this justify killing of Indian Muslims today? Third is the reference to Kashmiri Pandits. No one can say that the pogrom of 1991 was correct. This government has made Kashmir a union territory. It is in their power to restore status quo ante and relocate the families of displaced Pandits back to the land of their fathers. I for one will fully support such a move. At the same time the 2002 Gujarat riots should also be reinvestigated and those responsible for mass killings, from both religions, should be punished. That includes Maya Kodnani.

Unfortunately, with 2022 UP elections and 2024 Lok Sabha coming up, the hysteria and noise from the Hindutva lobby (not Hindu - there is a vast difference), is going to reach a double crescendo. I just hope that majority of Indians don't get carried away like they did after Pulwama in 2019 and gifted Modi another 5 years.

Expand full comment

Your Muslim brothers has crossed the red line in Bangladesh still no condemnation from prominent Indian Muslims like you.. shame on you including Indians hindoos liberals..

Expand full comment

You are one courageous lady. Full power to you for calling a spade a spade. Indeed, India is a fascist state. Some people are still living in denial.

Expand full comment

No one takes her seriously in India or any parts of the world . Only jihadi nation and people takes her seriously

Expand full comment

You are one helluva contradiction pal !

On the one hand you claim that Ms Ayyub is not taken seriously in India or elsewhere. But then, you spend so much time and effort to disprove her, attack her and malign her. Why do you do that if she is so discredited as you and your shaka buddies claim she is ? Clearly, she hits the nail on the head and you are unable to counter her with facts, figures and civilised argument right ?

And let me apply your pathetic logic on yourself. You assert:

".. Only jihadi nation and people takes her seriously .."

Since you are indeed taking Ms Ayyub seriously enough to write at length about her, you must yourself be from a jihadi nation and also a jihadi person?

And in any case, India, under Modi has indeed declared jihad on Muslims in the country hasn't it ?

Expand full comment

Each word of this article is 10000% true.India is hell under Rioter Modi.

Expand full comment

DragonOct 22

So so so many lies in this article. Here are just a few:

Lie number 1: She calls Nathuram Gods a terrorist. This is false. He was an assissin. There's a difference.

Lie number 2: "discriminatory Citizenship bill and the National register of Citizens that seeks proof of nationality from its Muslim population" The CAA has nothing to do with Indian muslims. It is for granting citizenship to persecuted minorities from 3 neighbouring muslim countries. The NRC hasn't even been drafted yet, and it is supposed to make a list of legal citizens in India, both muslim and otherwise. It's not like it'll only question indian muslims or something. What a shameless liar🙄

Lie number 3: "Kapil Mishra held a rally where they gave incendiary speeches against traitors and anti-nationalists (by which they clearly meant Indian Muslims)" How do u know?????? How do u know he meant only and all Indian muslims?????? Rana has no evidence

Lie number 4: "anti Muslim riot" WRONG!! The Delhi riots on the 24th were clearly anti-Hindu in nature. Molotov cocktails were found on the terrace of Tahir Hussain. He and other muslims present shouted "Maro Kaafiro ko!" before gutting Hindus. A constable(Hindu) was killed. IB officer Ankit Sharma's body was mutilated and thrown in the gutter. Dilbar Negi's body was burned. According to confessions of Tahir hussain himself and a number of muslims with him, they planned the riots a long time back b4 they happened. This is all documented in the chargesheets filed by Delhi police. Also well compiled by OpIndia, which did a great job covering the riots.

Lie number 5: "Assam, where thousands of Muslims are being expelled from their homes of their forefathers?" Nope!! They were illegal Bangladeshis who were illegally squatting on Indian land. That's y they were removed

Expand full comment

Then what is stopping you, go back to your beloved nation Pakistan and sell donkeys and learn hate against minorities.

Expand full comment

So so so many lies in this article. Here are just a few:

Lie number 1: She calls Nathuram Gods a terrorist. This is false. He was an assissin. There's a difference.

Lie number 2: "discriminatory Citizenship bill and the National register of Citizens that seeks proof of nationality from its Muslim population" The CAA has nothing to do with Indian muslims. It is for granting citizenship to persecuted minorities from 3 neighbouring muslim countries. The NRC hasn't even been drafted yet, and it is supposed to make a list of legal citizens in India, both muslim and otherwise. It's not like it'll only question indian muslims or something. What a shameless liar🙄

Lie number 3: "Kapil Mishra held a rally where they gave incendiary speeches against traitors and anti-nationalists (by which they clearly meant Indian Muslims)" How do u know?????? How do u know he meant only and all Indian muslims?????? Rana has no evidence

Lie number 4: "anti Muslim riot" WRONG!! The Delhi riots on the 24th were clearly anti-Hindu in nature. Molotov cocktails were found on the terrace of Tahir Hussain. He and other muslims present shouted "Maro Kaafiro ko!" before gutting Hindus. A constable(Hindu) was killed. IB officer Ankit Sharma's body was mutilated and thrown in the gutter. Dilbar Negi's body was burned. According to confessions of Tahir hussain himself and a number of muslims with him, they planned the riots a long time back b4 they happened. This is all documented in the chargesheets filed by Delhi police. Also well compiled by OpIndia, which did a great job covering the riots.

Lie number 5: "Assam, where thousands of Muslims are being expelled from their homes of their forefathers?" Nope!! They were illegal Bangladeshis who were illegally squatting on Indian land. That's y they were removed.

Expand full comment

At the end of the day only Truth prevails no matter how much lie one may put into it.. you done a very nice rebuttal of all the points which was raised.. keep it up doing good work for humanity..

Expand full comment

Kitne paise khaaye andh ye sab ulat pulat karke bataneke...

Expand full comment

Ek cheez bata librandu khainke kya jhut bola hai meine??? Koi ek jhut bata de bas. Bewakoof 🙄🙄

Expand full comment

Why don't you call him a hero instead of an assassin asshole? It's bcoz of assholes like you exist in India, that people like modi is still in power. Get some sense atleast to save yourself from raising petrol and diesel prices

Expand full comment

Y would I call him a hero. He was a colossal idiot whose actions were a blow to the progressive Hindutva movement. And yeah, I proudly voted for Modi in 2019😊. Dumbasses like urself won't understand. Ad hominem attacks are all you know. And yeah.. me and a plethora of friends I know are gonna vote for him again.. and again. Go get bent.

Expand full comment

And have the guts to login with your name, Modi's bootlicker 🤣

Expand full comment

Feel sad for India, when beings like you exist, guess what I couldn't even label you as people. Anyways there is proverb, a dog shits and eats its own shit, and you are that kind. Go and lick your own shit asshole.

Expand full comment

🤣🤣lol I don't give a crap how u feel. And I don't understand y u care about India so much anyways. I'll vote for Modi proudly. There hindutva movement will prevail. I don't care if it bothers u. Get bent shithead

Expand full comment

Okay I wasted my time on an asshole like you, thinking I can knock some sense into your head, I should've known you are one of those dumbheads, who only go do anything on the name of hindutva, and a whole population of shitheads like you exist 🤣

Expand full comment

Tell me exactly when you tried to "knock some sense" into me??? What have u done other repeat the word asshole a thousand times?? The Hindutva movement is the strongest progressive force in this country, and I love it♥️ if u think u wasted time, then GO AWAY! Y r u even replying to me I'm not forcing u too. Poopbrain wasting precious minutes of my life that I'll never get back🙄🙄 goodbye shithead

Expand full comment

Ho and re watch terrorist Kapil mishra' s videos.RSS is terrorist organization so its members. Godse was first terrorist of independent India. Read CAA and NRC rules it will show u how only muslims are targetted by Rioter Modi and Tadipar gunda Amit Shah.

Expand full comment

Kapil Mishra's exact words were "Hum sadak pe utar jaege" There's no direct threat of violence there. Godse wasn't a terrorist, he was an assassin and there's a difference. Has an RSS member ever strapped a suicide bomb to his chest and exploded in the middle of a packed group of ppl??? Go read the definition of a terrorist first. Nope. Tell me where it says in CAA that shows that muslims are targetted??? Which line specifically???? Here is the pdf of it. https://egazette.nic.in/WriteReadData/2019/214646.pdf

Please show me where it is written that muslims are targetted. And pls give me the link to the NRC bill that PM Narendra Modi has personally sent to u🙄🙄

Expand full comment

No3. Kapil Sarma was ushering anti national slogans against a particular community

He was responsible for such Danga

Expand full comment

Tahir Hussain and other muslims confessed to Delhi police that they planned the danga many days prior. They prepared Molotov cocktails in their houses and chanted "Kafiro ko maro!" whilst butchering Hindus. This is what they themselves said to Delhi police do don't try to divert from it.

Expand full comment

Your comment on Assam is totally frustrated/zero knowledge/intentional lie, Bcoz not a single Bangladeshi citizens squatting on Indian land. They are all 1000 times genuine citizens of India and lived in beaches of river Brahmaputra bcoz their own parmanent land was eroded. They are cultivated in beaches accordingly and contribute to their own country well. Eviction was ill intention to become them poorest. So don't share misinformation publicly.

Expand full comment

First of all, please learn English. Or talk in Hindi it is ok. Second, did you know that it was a Muslim fellow who brought to the attention of the high court that Bangladeshis were illegally encroaching on government land? You probably didn't know that, because u only read Rana Ayyub🙄🙄 The land belonged to the government, not to them. Here is an article about it please read:

https://www.opindia.com/2021/09/hindus-darrang-district-assam-busts-lies-eviction-drive-violence-watch/

And don't get frustrated while reading asshole, your Ummah is illegally encroaching on Indian land and inshallah they will be evicted at the earliest

Expand full comment

Can't you write something new? Same freaking stuff written in all your other articles

Expand full comment

And same killing of innocent nationals seem to be fine for you.

Expand full comment

All rubbish full of lie and deciet. Few example are 1.She quotes SC on Modi but fails to mention that same SC termed her book "Gujarat files as work of fiction & lies " . 2. CAA is about giving faster citizenship to minorities of neighbouring Islam countries 3. Protest against Azaan was at Gurugram and not in Capital Delhi and moreover they were doing azaan on Govt land and in the midst of residential area.4. Nathuram Godse was an ex RSS member ..How much lie she tellls. Their is lie in each and every line. Some one needs to counter her hate propaganda. She never condemns terrorist attack on Hindu or Sikhs or even attack by Maoists on villagers. Shah Rukh became Super star because of love from all sections Same Yusuf Khan and other stars had to change to Dilip Kumar to get accepted by Indians 60-70 years ago

Expand full comment

Rana ayub I hate you and you have my curse , you are going to be burn in hell. God is not going to forgive you for encouraging violence and terrorism in India. You are a most deadliest poinsnous snake born in India. You look one swine poop. You are a human blood sucker . You are being ruled by Satan . Keep spreading false porpagnda nothing will work but because of your article more hate will be build in our society which you are day and night working for . Wake up and do something good in your life my jihadi sister.

Expand full comment

There is nothing wrong with this article, she just explaines facts. The true Hindu religion, like many other religions, also spreads the message of peace. Murder, bloodshed, racism, hate, that is not peace. It is you who needs to wake up and realise that to build a peacefull society you have to fight for humanity, in spite of religion. And not acknowledging facts or looking the other way and pretending nothing happend, is you being part of the problem. Not the solution.

Expand full comment

My friend ym, what are you saying do you know we can't clap with one hands likewise we can't build peacefull society and fight for humanity when you people have jihadi mindset and hate for non believers and this is promoted in your holy scriptures. How can we have solution when you create terms like "Hindu terrorist " to target peacefull and most tolerant religious community in the world.. why would a hindu like me support her if she only gives bias one side reporting only . I haven't seen her speaking about crime and injustice done against hindus in India and atrocities carried out against Kashmiri pundits and the suffering of Pakistan, Bangladeshi Hindus . Where were she when recently jihadis attacked hindus temples in Bangladesh . When hindus are victim she goes hiding under the blanket. If the hindus are losing patience it is because we had enough of this jihadis and everything has a limit my friend.. your liberal and secular thinking is respected but please don't only preach this but show some actions also.

Expand full comment

Just proved her point. Good job.

Expand full comment

Haha lol 😂

Yes, She proved that she is number one news reporter for jihadis .

Expand full comment

What is Hindu terrorist ? There is no such word as hindu terrorist. How can you associate terrorist with hindus are you insane. No where in the world anyone calls Hindu terrorist stop making your self look like a fool.

Expand full comment

The article lacks facts . She is the one who goes hiding when hindus are attacked by jihadis. She is a rana ayub the most poisonous snake of India.

Expand full comment

Rana ayub if India is so much unsafe for Muslims then why do you want rohigyas Muslim to be given shelter in India.

Expand full comment

Great point! 👏

Expand full comment

And you are fake journalist who does not the difference between a murderer and terrorist. You lost all my respect by using the term hindu terrorist.

Expand full comment

This is the most ignorant and double standard statement I have come across so far. I would go on to argue at the self-righteousness of it that is childish and baffling but apparently it is something that can't be accomplished so easily. I will leave it to time and luck that hopefully you will understand the enormity of the problem such callous and narrow-minded thinking will cause.

Expand full comment

What a complete piece of shit this article is. It truly shows your entire career is based on playing the victim rather than reporting actual facts. You are the epitome of showering one sided narratives that suit your propaganda rather than maintaining any journalistic ethos. Completely shameless and hopeless reporting. The amount of lies you have spewn. For example, those killed in Assam weren't living in the land of their forefathers. They were illegal immigrants occupying goverment land, but you just tried to change the narrative. Do you know most actual Assamese muslims don't even like these illegals that you are trying to glorify? The photographer didn't jump over the dead body because he was a muslim. He jumped because that person who was killed was chasing the photographer with a machete, before being shot dead. But facts don't matter to you. So it was an act of rage rather than an act of religious intolerance, even though what he did was wrong, bringing religion in for every issue is such a unethical form of journalism. May allah actually guide you to realise that your hate mongering business has really gone out of control. Shame, shame.

Expand full comment

Please read the article first. There are no made up stories. Hundreds of media reported it. Rana only voiced it here based on what has happened recently. Now if u turn blind eye to the facts turns you a facist as well. She is exactly saying the same.

Expand full comment

Doesn't matter if millions of media report it🙄 A lie is a lie. Period. No one's turning a blind eye except Rana herself.

Expand full comment

So the man was killed and a photographer was dancing on it is a lie. Rape culture in delhi increased is a lie. Killing muslims on the name of cow meat is a lie. How can a secular state gives so much power to common man to kill other

Expand full comment

Nope rape culture is not a lie. Girls should always be safe in this nation. Killing Muslims in name of cow meat is not a lie. You should be able to eat whatever the fuck you want to eat be it a cow, pig, frog, spider, without people stopping your personal free will. But yeah, the photographer dancing on a dead man is a lie. The photographer pounced on the dead body multiple times in act to cause harm. What he did was wrong in every manner, but it nothing to do with religion. He did it in an act of rage as I mentioned because the person whom the police shot dead was actually trying to harm the photographer with a machete and running behind him, and therefore the photographer tried to take his revenge after the person fell down after being shot. RELIGION HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH IT. STOP BRINGING RELIGION IN EVERY FUCKING ASPECT OF THIS NATION.

Expand full comment

Ur right. Ppl are too quick to insert the religious angle everywhere without ascertaining the actual facts.

Expand full comment

No bro🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️Reread the comment that Dick posted which u replied to. He has mentioned what the lies are very clearly. Ur stupidity lvl is very high. Stop changing the subject and focus on what he has written

Expand full comment

Par for the course for this fake "journalist." The garbage from Rana is expected. What is sad is so many well-meaning, educated people are taken in. She is the real hate monger taking advantage of liberal democracy to destroy it from within. If India were a fascist state, she'd have been silenced a long time back. You want to see an actual religio-fascist state, go to any of our neighbors - Pakistan or Bangladesh. When you are accustomed to preferential treatment, any hint of equality seems like discrimination.

Expand full comment

Rana Ayyub is clearly a Pakistani agent or somebody who really hates Hindus and Indian people, and the Indian nation itself. She should be assasinated by R&AW or by any Hindu who wants to take her out. So should all the Islamists writing articles for Washington Post or New York Times who insult Hindus and India. For some reason western news outlets disproportionately hire MUZZLIM trash to report on India

Expand full comment

Please correct her and clarify even one fact she mentioned to be a lie

Expand full comment

Lie number 1: She calls Nathuram Gods a terrorist. This is false. He was an assissin. There's a difference.

Lie number 2: "discriminatory Citizenship bill and the National register of Citizens that seeks proof of nationality from its Muslim population" The CAA has nothing to do with Indian muslims. It is for granting citizenship to persecuted minorities from 3 neighbouring muslim countries. The NRC hasn't even been drafted yet, and it is supposed to make a list of legal citizens in India, both muslim and otherwise. It's not like it'll only question indian muslims or something. What a shameless liar🙄

Lie number 3: "Kapil Mishra held a rally where they gave incendiary speeches against traitors and anti-nationalists (by which they clearly meant Indian Muslims)" How do u know?????? How do u know he meant only and all Indian muslims?????? Rana has no evidence

Lie number 4: "anti Muslim riot" WRONG!! The Delhi riots on the 24th were clearly anti-Hindu in nature. Molotov cocktails were found on the terrace of Tahir Hussain. He and other muslims present shouted "Maro Kaafiro ko!" before gutting Hindus. A constable(Hindu) was killed. IB officer Ankit Sharma's body was mutilated and thrown in the gutter. Dilbar Negi's body was burned. According to confessions of Tahir hussain himself and a number of muslims with him, they planned the riots a long time back b4 they happened. This is all documented in the chargesheets filed by Delhi police. Also well compiled by OpIndia, which did a great job covering the riots.

Lie number 5: "Assam, where thousands of Muslims are being expelled from their homes of their forefathers?" Nope!! They were illegal Bangladeshis who were illegally squatting on Indian land. That's y they were removed.

Expand full comment

Can anyone of you assholes deny a single account of what she's written?. You calling her fake based on what?? Your sanghi asses are not used to factual reporting.. i get it.

Expand full comment

Lie number 1: She calls Nathuram Gods a terrorist. This is false. He was an assissin. There's a difference.

Lie number 2: "discriminatory Citizenship bill and the National register of Citizens that seeks proof of nationality from its Muslim population" The CAA has nothing to do with Indian muslims. It is for granting citizenship to persecuted minorities from 3 neighbouring muslim countries. The NRC hasn't even been drafted yet, and it is supposed to make a list of legal citizens in India, both muslim and otherwise. It's not like it'll only question indian muslims or something. What a shameless liar🙄

Lie number 3: "Kapil Mishra held a rally where they gave incendiary speeches against traitors and anti-nationalists (by which they clearly meant Indian Muslims)" How do u know?????? How do u know he meant only and all Indian muslims?????? Rana has no evidence

Lie number 4: "anti Muslim riot" WRONG!! The Delhi riots on the 24th were clearly anti-Hindu in nature. Molotov cocktails were found on the terrace of Tahir Hussain. He and other muslims present shouted "Maro Kaafiro ko!" before gutting Hindus. A constable(Hindu) was killed. IB officer Ankit Sharma's body was mutilated and thrown in the gutter. Dilbar Negi's body was burned. According to confessions of Tahir hussain himself and a number of muslims with him, they planned the riots a long time back b4 they happened. This is all documented in the chargesheets filed by Delhi police. Also well compiled by OpIndia, which did a great job covering the riots.

Lie number 5: "Assam, where thousands of Muslims are being expelled from their homes of their forefathers?" Nope!! They were illegal Bangladeshis who were illegally squatting on Indian land. That's y they were removed

Expand full comment