When Rana Ayyub met Narendra Modi

An excerpt from my book, Gujarat Files

In the year 2010, I wrote this cover story for Tehelka titled ‘Why is this man still free?’

I had culled out and published not just then Gujarat Home Minister, Amit Shah’s call records but also an internal note by the state CID in Gujarat that was monitoring his movements. Within a few weeks, Mr. Shah was arrested, I was asked to submit a copy of the call records to the Central Bureau of Investigation that was handling the case that was later presented to the Supreme Court of India.

Right after this pathbreaking expose, I published an investigation into the Madhavpura co-operative bank scam that involved corruption to the tune of 1600 crores. My expose among other things documented that in the year 2005, the then Additional DGP, CID, Crime (Gujarat)Kuldeep Sharma had written to the Chief Secretary of Gujarat under Chief Minister Narendra Modi, that Amit Shah had taken bribe worth 2.5 crores to help the main accused in the case, Ketan Parekh secure bail from the court. That letter it was accused was buried by the Modi government.

Many here, who have been readers of Tehelka will know that our entire website and work has been wiped off the internet. But they say images stay. Fortunately some newspapers including the Hindustan Times had done follow ups and covered the scam in depth (https://www.hindustantimes.com/india/shah-took-2-5-crore-bribe-from-scamster/story-QbfWmmYYSrkUfYLK7DGygN.html)

Shah

Soon after publishing these stories, I had gone undercover to expose the complicity of Narendra Modi and Amit Shah and their administration in Gujarat that was laced with accusations of hundreds of criminal cases documented by local newspapers. I was accompanied by a French colleague, Mike who posed as my Assistant Director and researcher. Once the investigation that lasted more than six months was over, we finally met Narendra Modi. I write about the meeting in a chapter in my self-published book, Gujarat Files. I am publishing the chapter here, for my readers today. The entire transcripts of the taped conversations with top cops, bureaucrats, ministers are published in my book, Gujarat Files-Anatomy of a Cover up. Those who intend to get a copy, the book is available on Amazon

Here is the chapter. Do read

---

Mike and I had reached Modi’s Gandhinagar residence an hour early. So we asked our driver to park our car close by while we waited for the clock to tick faster. I was nervous while Mike kept smiling. My concern was that if the camera in my watch caught the attention of the security check and the metal barriers, we were done for. Half an hour later when we walked into the CM’s residence I breathed easy when I walked through security without being caught.

Modi’s OSD Sanjay Bhavsar met us. We were finally escorted to the CM’s room. He stood up to greet us. Mike exclaimed that he had seen his posters in the autos in Ahmedabad and was very impressed with his popularity. On the table were two books on Barack Obama. “So will you be the next PM sir?” I asked immediately. He blushed and started to speak about Barack Obama who was his inspiration and the virtues of Swami Vivekananda. After a 30-minute chat, the CM called Bhavsar to his room and asked him to show us the material that had been written about him. Bhavsar took us to his cabin. On his table were printouts of stories published by Tehelka and The Hindu on the CM. I enquired about them to which Bhavsar replied that the CM had too many enemies. I think I almost heard Mike chuckle. Later we were shown the various books the CM had authored and made to listen to recordings of his speeches in India and around the world.

Bhavsar asked me to get a copy of all of them as it would help in my film making. I said I would do so on my next visit. We went back home and Mike packed his bags, he had a flight to catch to Delhi. I hugged him as I called him a cab to the airport. Minutes later Mike called to tell me that he could not locate a single rupee in his pocket when he reached the airport and the taxi driver did not just waive the fare but also gave him Rs 200 for his journey. Mike said this was what he wanted to take away from Gujarat. I agreed wholeheartedly. That was the last time I saw Mike and I am sure wherever he is, he will remember Maithili, his older sister and comrade-in-arms.

I called up Shoma and gave her the details right after. She asked me if I had questioned the CM about the riots. “Come on Shoma, that’s the last thing I would do on my first visit,” I retorted. Later in the evening I got a call from Shoma saying, “Come back to Delhi, Rana’. I had just about started to protest when she said she would explain once I was back.

The next morning I reached Delhi and went straight to the Tehelka office. I had transferred the footage of the Modi recording to my laptop. Tarun was in his cabin. Shoma joined him. I showed them the footage and they laughed looking at the books by Obama.

“So, why was I called back?” I asked. “His office will call me in a few days and I am supposed to meet him again.”
Tarun said, “Look Rana, after the Tehelka sting on Bangaru Laxman they shut our office. Modi is all set to be the most powerful man, the PM. If we touch him we will be finished.”

I was not convinced. Was the entire sting operation not a big risk in itself? But I was given a sharp No to every argument.

The same evening Sanjay Bhavsar called me. I let the phone ring. He called three times and then left a text that the CM would love to see me the following Sunday. I went to a local PCO and called Bhavsar to tell him that I was in Delhi and that a relative had passed away and I was required in the city. I assured him however that I would get back to him in a week’s time. Two days later I removed the Uninor sim card from my phone, crushed it and threw it in the dustbin. I did the same with the phone. Maithili made an exit forever that day. The editors took a call that the investigation would not be published.

I have remained silent since.

Till now.

(First published in Gujarat Files-Anatomy of a Cover-up)